Posted on 2 Comments

Are we REALLY moving in the right direction #YEG? [ “legalizing” helicopter parenting]

I’ve seen it pop up a lot over the past couple of weeks. I’ve seen in it parking lots, billboard signs, sponsored Facebook posts.

It bothers me. I wish it didn’t, but it does.

The sign I’m talking about is the Edmonton Police Service “A vehicle is not a babysitter” campaign.

With this campaign, community members are encouraged to call 911, and given power to break the window in someone’s vehicle if they believe the child(ren) inside the car are in distress.

I guess the first reason it bothered me is because it made me feel like a bad parent. I know I’m not a bad parent, and I am pretty sure a lot of people would agree to that, and still, that sign made me feel like one.

Call me old school. Call me a bad mom. But I have left my children alone in the car. We were driving home from work, when I remembered we didn’t have any milk. I parked in front of one of those small gas station convenience stores, activated the command start so the AC could run and the car would be at a comfortable and safe temperature. They were both happily in their car seats and the doors were locked. I was gone for as long as it takes to buy a bottle of milk and could see the car at all times. I got the milk, got back in the car, and we went on with our day.

Do I feel bad for leaving them in the car? No. I assessed the situation and made a parenting decision I felt comfortable with. But if someone had seen me, and called 911, all of a sudden, a rational parenting decision would have turned me into a neglectful and criminal parent.

Doesn’t that seem a little extreme to you?

Do I leave my children alone in the car as a habit? Of course not. It was situational. I didn’t neglect or abandon them; I made a parenting decision.

I go even further. Had someone called the police and there had been no clear reasonable or probable grounds for the call (other than the fact that I was not physically in the car with them… but could still see them at all times) – Do I have the right to call the police on the person who reported me, for harassment and unnecessary emotional distress? I should also add, that if the child’s well being is what we’re concerned about, a random stranger creeping on my kids through a window will definitely causes them distress – I digress…

If my children are safe, and I have made a rational parenting decision, someone calling the police on me is just plain and simple harassment.

Parenting is stressful enough as it is, and now even more power is taken away from mothers (YES, mothers! Because we all know Dads are not judged nearly as harshly as mothers are) to be potentially criminalized on something that is subjective.

In the article “Motherhood in the Age of Fear” by  Kim Brooks published in the New York Times, she says:

” ‘I don’t know if I’m afraid for my kids, or if I’m afraid other people will be afraid and will judge me for my lack of fear.’ “

And she’s right!

It’s this really about safety? Or is “danger” something we are letting society subjectively decide?

I agree that a car is not a babysitter.

I want my children to be safe.

I would never leave my children in a car to overheat or freeze, like COME ON! No good parent would!


Is this trend in parenting going to continue?

How much more monitored is parenting going to get? How much more over protective are parents forced to be with their children? How much more power is going to be taken away from mothers when it comes to weighing situations and making parenting choices?

Everyone always talks about how they wish things were like they were before, yet as a society, we directly contribute to not getting there. As a mother, I’m forced to raise children who won’t know what it’s like not be constantly watched and monitored, and the only crime we are committing here, is stealing away our children’s right to independence and to little bit of damn freedom.

Mothering in the age of fear and criticism is reaching such levels, that there are states in the United States where “free range” parents have had to be protected by law, as seen here in a CNN story about “free range kids”.

It takes a village to raise a child, yes. But are we OK letting the villages voice outweigh the parent’s decisions and choices?

I am not.

I can’t be the only who feels this way. I hope I’m not.


2 thoughts on “Are we REALLY moving in the right direction #YEG? [ “legalizing” helicopter parenting]

  1. Ahh, it is so refreshing to read this. I do believe there is a big problem as a society on this topic. I was in a situation much like the one you’re describing at a small store that I shop at frequently but an elderly gentleman followed me into the store and once I was in the produce section he loudly accosted me for leaving my kids in the car. Even asked me if I cared about them at all or wanted them to die. I pleaded with him to please not treat me this way, told him that I love my kids and would never knowingly put them in danger but he continued until I was in my car with the door locked. The kids asked if I had got the snacks they wanted and I just fell apart crying. I had never been talked to that way about my parenting choices. In the end the kids didn’t get their snacks and then we were all in tears together, and not because I had left them in the car for a few short minutes but because I had been unnecessarily accosted by a stranger. I would love to see this change for the better. I do believe campaigns like this were intended to protect children with negligent parents who are in fact in danger, but now people use these campaigns to be “superhero’s” with their 15 minutes of internet fame. Post a picture or video of a poor child stuck in a car and you saving the day breaking the window and you get all kinds of praise. It’s sad. It becomes more about being a part of the majority (the majority standing against leaving kids in the car) and less about what is in fact best for the child. Man, I guess I have a lot of strong feelings about this too, but to end this long rant I’ll say, no. You’re not alone in feeling this way, and I really appreciate you taking this hot topic and putting out your view, even though it seems these days this isn’t the most popular of opinions. ❤️❤️

    1. Thank you for your comment my friend. I’m glad I wasn’t alone in my thoughts, and I hope that this is the step in the right direction to make sure that we are able to keep the power of parenting in the hands of well, (good) parents. Your story is what makes me angry about society nowadays. They feel like for the “child’s safety” (if that really is the concern) they are able to abuse and harass women (because they would never talk like that to a man) and if more power is given to strangers, I can only imagine how bad it can get. Hugs my friend. You didn’t deserve that.

Leave a Reply